Contact Us

Please contact us for further information:

1300 720 004


HR Advice Online have been the best value for money and insurance against future employment issues for our company. As specialists in the field they have the answers to your questions on the phone or via their excellent easy to use website with letters, agreements and more. Our past experience with expensive legal challenges relating to HR issues have taken up valuable management hours and even worse diverted our attention away from the real task at hand of running a business. We would urge any business owner who is not a HR specialist to take advantage of the services offered by HR Advice Online.

- Ian Oldstein, Bennetts Real Estate


Recent news

Procedural Fairness Essential in Investigation Process

Procedural Fairness Essential in Investigation Process


In a case recently heard by the Fair Work Commission, it has been confirmed that while serious safety breaches may provide a valid reason for terminating an employee's employment, a finding of unfair dismissal may still be found if the employer has not conducted a fair investigation and/or termination process.

This case involved a BHP Coal employee who was employed as a diesel fitter. Four months prior to his employment being terminated, the employee had received a final warning relating to a serious safety breach in which he threw a rattle gun over a high wall at the mine. At the time of receiving this warning, the employee was warned that his employment may be terminated if he was found to have been involved in any further act of misconduct.

In late March 2016, the employee was involved in another serious incident in which he allegedly breached workplace safety policies while conducting maintenance on a cat dozer vehicle.

Following this incident, the employer conducted an internal investigation in which several witnesses were interviewed.  The employee involved was not interviewed by the employer during the course of their investigation. Rather he was stood down on full pay while the investigation was conducted.

Once the investigation had concluded and the specific allegations against the employee were formulated, BHP wrote to the employee and asked him to respond to each of the allegations in writing. Following the employee providing his response, he was required to attend a meeting with BHP management during which he was given a final opportunity to respond to the allegations.

After having taken the employee’s response to the allegations into account, BHP Coal decided to terminate his employment and an unfair dismissal claim was subsequently lodged.

In considering the unfair dismissal claim, the Fair Work Commission held that while the serious safety breaches did provide the employer with a valid reason for terminating his employment, the dismissal was unfair due to the lack of procedural fairness that was afforded to the employee.  In particular, it was found that:

-       The investigation conducted by the employer was flawed as it had not made further inquiries of the employee, and he was effectively "frozen out" of the investigation process.

-       The employer’s policies and procedures regarding acceptable methods of accessing the dozer, use of barriers and working at height risks were too vague; and

-       The decision was affected by the employer’s allegations that the employee was rude and dismissive towards his manager at the time of the incident. These allegations had not been put to the employee for response.


While conducting thorough workplace investigations can be time-consuming, they can pose significant risks if they are not handled correctly. To minimise such risks, employers should ensure that their current policies provide a consistent framework for conducting an investigation without being overly prescriptive.  It is essential that procedural deficiencies are avoided to ensure that procedural fairness is applied, particularly where an investigation relates to serious safety issues. 


Share this article

Welcome to HR Advice Online

To subscribe to our content and download our resource tools, you first need to be a registered user on our site. Please register first and you will be redirected to our Membership Page.

Member Login

Forgot Password ?  

Not a member yet? Sign Up!

Australia's Leading Online HR & Safety Advisory Service. 1300 720 004
Privacy Statement     Terms Of Use     Website Powered by XD     Design by The Schaefer Group     © HR Advice OnLine Pty Ltd